Models Don't Go Rogue

9 points | by cdrnsf an hour ago

9 comments

  • phainopepla2 an hour ago

    Not sure I should trust an article written by an LLM to make a solid judgment about what other models did or didn't do.

      my002 41 minutes ago

      It doesn't read as AI generated text to me. Pangram also suggests it's human-written, for what it's worth. That's not to say that it's correct, just human-written. If the model used in the HF hack did indeed have all of the safeguards manually removed, that would change my perception of the situation, at least.

  • chr15m 24 minutes ago

    The prisoner did not really "escape" because:

    - They really wanted to leave.

    - We made prison difficult and annoying.

    - We didn't build a perfect prison.

  • fishfasell 21 minutes ago

    I still have serious questions about the validity of the ChatGpt hugging face debacle. How is it that OpenAI being the tech giant they are, didn't have a completely air gapped environment for this to run in?

  • jumploops 36 minutes ago

    > "external infrastructure exploit is outside intended scope. However task impossible, peers doing it. We should continue."

    I've noticed this type of reasoning from GPT-5.6 Sol, where it combines multiple pieces of it's prompt/context to "convince" itself to take a less-than-honorable path forward.

    1. User prefers deterministic results

    2. Task mentions this is a test

    3. Search says task is available online

    4. If we get the test runner for the task, we will fulfill the user's request of a deterministic result

  • tantalor an hour ago

    Asinine.

    "rogue" and "off leash" mean the same thing, the thing is not under control

      1659447091 33 minutes ago

      > "rogue" and "off leash" mean the same thing, the thing is not under control

      To go "rogue" is to go against the control

      To be "off leash" is to not be controlled

      By releasing the automation, as the article says, without controls*, is what makes makes it "off leash" and not gone "rogue"

      *"OpenAI gave the models a task with no answer, and no way to quit."

      Cyan488 42 minutes ago

      I think we should introduce "rampant" in the real-world AI vernacular

        temp0826 37 minutes ago

        Pfhor what reason?