The AI Aesthetic

42 points | by montroser an hour ago

20 comments

  • jjcm 32 minutes ago

    > There are other aesthetics my brain associates with AI, like beige/cream colors, orange accents, and serif typefaces

    Something to consider regarding the narrow space AI-created designs align on: LLMs are trained to write consistent code. This makes sense for something like a billing or a backend function - you want that code to be consistent. The problem though is that LLMs write code to represent designs as well, which means you get consistent designs. You end up aligning on a generic mean because of it, which is often why you see these repeated aesthetics.

    It was something I saw when I was working on AI tooling over at Figma. It was very hard to get creative, unique outputs out of LLMs.

    One thing I'd recommend if you're trying to avoid this is try a diffusion model as a starting point. Gpt-image-2 is a VERY capable designer, and Opus and Fable are fantastic at converting images to webpages. Starting with images will let you sidestep a lot of the uniformity of output that LLMs have. I'm heavily biased here as this is what I left figma to build (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48995754), but even starting with gpt-image-2 to give you a general sense of the look/feel will heavily differentiate you on the design front.

    Here are some examples of image->webpage outputs I've been playing with:

    https://html.non.io/tarot/

    https://html.non.io/neonRamen/

      sebmellen 25 minutes ago

      How do you prompt your diffusion models? I see that you are a founder in this space :)

      p-e-w 7 minutes ago

      > The problem though is that LLMs write code to represent designs as well, which means you get consistent designs. You end up aligning on a generic mean because of it, which is often why you see these repeated aesthetics.

      The funny thing is that looking like everyone else was once considered the definition of good UI design, because it helps users understand a new interface. Then mobile apps came and suddenly UI design was about “expressing your brand” or whatever.

  • dgunay 10 minutes ago

    There's definitely a lot of AI-generated websites, especially for dev tools & SaaS, that love to have dark backgrounds, cool colors (purple especially is making a resurgence it seems), and tons of fancy UI widgets.

  • AsyncBanana 35 minutes ago

    A lot of these things are continuations of previous trends too. The shimmering text effect is strongly reminiscent of skeleton UI, only repurposed for chat interfaces. As always, design is more continuous evolution than discrete shifts.

      collingreen 12 minutes ago

      As the saying goes: Slowly, then all at once.

  • A_D_E_P_T 11 minutes ago

    > before AI what were the connotations of the sparkle emoji ?

    It generally stood for either:

    - fireworks (combined with other firework emojis,)

    - birthdays/festivals (next to the birthday cake and "party popper" thing emoji,)

    - magic (next to the wizard or wand, which features almost identical sparkles)

    It was pretty festive. Now it's just AI, lol.

  • fidotron 33 minutes ago

    The defining "AI" aesthetic is the TUI, for better or worse.

    The real question is what the post-AI aesthetic will be, and at a guess it will bifurcate into obsessive recreations of earlier happier pre-AI times, and some sort of opposite extreme of videos of Chinese cities covered in LEDs.

  • cortesoft 15 minutes ago

    Is the "'shimmering text' for waiting" thing really that recent? I feel like that is a bit older, but maybe I am wrong. I have more and more difficulty remembering how long things have been around as I get older.

  • guessmyname 37 minutes ago

    > For example, there’s the hamburger menu (≡) which saw a proliferation during the rise of mobile due to the constraints around screen size.

    Speaking of this, GitHub replaced theirs with a pancake emoji.

    Maybe related to the stacked pull-requests announcement earlier today.

      genghisjahn 14 minutes ago

      That’s what that was. I thought someone there screwed up an image path.

  • aetherspawn 21 minutes ago

    The tiny icons are good. There was a touch device fad that surfaced, and is subsequently dying, now that people realise that using laptop screen realestate more efficiently helps those doing actual work.

  • Centigonal 11 minutes ago

    Another AI-ism is the use of the word "grain" in technical contexts. I'm confident the OP is human-written, but everything in my AI-supported codebase is about grains, seams, tracer bullets, and load-bearing components now.

    I'd barely heard some of these words before, and now they're everywhere. It's like everyone suddenly has a friend who speaks in the same idiosyncratic way, and we're all picking up their vocal stims.

  • hmokiguess 26 minutes ago

    Tangent but, I still know plenty of people who are not aware of the "hamburger menu" and also do not know it as such or reference it as such.

    The bubble in tech is pretty strange but I digress

  • anon373839 an hour ago

    How could an article on the AI aesthetic not mention the curiously anatomical company logos?

    On a more serious note, I like the tiny icon trend as depicted in the article. Those little icons next to menu text are pretty ornamental, and don't need to be as big as they usually are.

      piskov 36 minutes ago

      The issue with the icons is not the diameter but their stroke thickness — it should be the same as the letters.

        anon373839 27 minutes ago

        Oh, huh. I was focused on the scale but you’re right, they are kind of wispy. That reminds me of the anorexic typography trend from ~2013. It’s probably intended to convey sophistication.

      Waterluvian 41 minutes ago

      The nice thing about web and electron apps is you generally get zoom for free. I like the icons as they just kind of work better for my brain.

  • cyanregiment 20 minutes ago

    Uhh what? So shadcn, bad devs using small icons and antialiasing - I think this is all peripheral to AI aesthetics.

    Midjourney has a definite aesthetic.

    Minimax has one. Stable Diffusion definitely (ugly, but free )

    Sora everything is rendered in Octane lol

    If it’s cartoon or animated it’s Ghibli.

    I have not noticed “orange” as a particular AI trend.

  • nader an hour ago

    agree!